@ejworthing Galatea is great!
I have not played IF in recent years at all, but I recommend exploring the past winners of https://ifcomp.org/ and http://xyzzyawards.org/
My personal favorites in the genre were more long-form story focused: Anchorhead (1998, Lovecraftian horror in the style of Shadow of Innsmouth) and Slouching Towards Bedlam (2003, Steampunk Mystery) and The King of Shreds and Patches (2009, another Lovecraftian horror, set in Shakespearan London).